Get Your FREE Personal
Multivitamin Recommendation

We'll search our database of over 100 multivitamin brands
to find the Top 3 that match your needs most closely

Comparison of Over 100 Popular Multivitamin Brands

Most multivitamins you buy at your local store are not carefully formulated to give you the optimal nutrition you need. Their manufacturers use low-quality ingredients that are not potent or bioavailable enough to be beneficial. They may meet the government’s recommended daily intake guidelines, but they don’t use the type of nutrients that are most easily absorbed by your body.

For these reasons, the vast majority of multivitamins available today are simply not good enough to spend your hard-earned money on. You want the benefits of the best vitamin and mineral supplement you can find, but you’re not sure how to find the right multivitamin for your needs. We always recommend doing your own research instead of trying to wade through the marketing noise of most vitamin companies, and this Multivitamin Guide is a good start.

We’ve done indepth analysis of over 100 vitamin brands, including popular supplements such as Centrum, One-A-Day, GNC, Shaklee, Nutrilite/Amway, Equate, Nature Made, NOW Foods, Melaleuca, and Puritan’s Pride. We’ve also included many brands that are not so recognizable, including Xtend-Life, Douglas Labs and USANA.

Each of the reviewed vitamins was evaluated against four criteria, including composition, bioavailability, safety, and potency. Each supplement received a score ranging from 0 to 10 to help you easily compare the effectiveness of the different brands and determine the best multivitamin to take.

Effectiveness Scores of Popular Multivitamins

The table below provides a summary of the Effectiveness Scores of some of the more popular vitamin supplement brands available on the market. For the best vitamins, look for a score of 8.0 or above, which is considered excellent.

Most widely available supplements scored low in our review, while nine relatively unknown brands were the best scoring products.

Rank Manufacturer Product Score
1 Xtend-Life Natural Products Total Balance 4.81
2 NATURELO Premium Supplements Whole Food Multivitamin 4.72
3 Natures Plus Source of Life Original 4.60
4 Thorne  Multi-Vitamin Elite - Daily Nutritional Supp 4.56
5 Seeking Health Optimal Multivitamin 4.48
6 Kirkland Signature Organic Mutivitamin 4.20
7 Centrum  Multivitamin/Multimineral Supplement 4.02
8 NaturesPlus Source of Life Gold Liquid 4.00
9 Thorne  Advanced Nutrients Multivitamin & Mineral 3.96
10 Controlled Labs Orange Trap 3.94
11 NaturePlus SourceofLife Gold 3.82
12 Kirkland Signature 50+ Mature Multi 3.81
13 Nature Plus Source of Life  3.80
14 Centrum  Adults Multivitamin/Multimineral Supp 3.76
15 Metagenics PhytoMulti Without Iron-Daily Multivitamin 3.69
16 NOW Daily Vits Multivitamins and Mineral 3.64
17 Solgar Formula VM-75, 90 Tablets - Multivitamin 3.63
18 Nature's Way Max3 Potency Daily Multivitamin 3.62
19 Thorne  Basic Nutrients 2/Day 3.61
20 Controlled Labs Orange Triad 3.57
21 Advanced Bariatrics Bariatric Mulivitamin Chewable Tablets 3.57
22 365 Whole Foods Market Adult Multivitamin with Iron 3.54
23 VeganVitality Multi-Vitamin and Minerals 3.53
24 Sports Research  Organic Greens  3.49
25 Solaray Liposomal Multivitamin for Men 3.47
26 NaturesPlus Source of Life Gold Multivitamin 3.41
27 Nordic Naturals Men's Multi  3.33
28 NOW Liquid Multi gels 3.33
29 Mary Ruth's Liquid Morning Multivitamin + Hair Growth 3.33
30 One a Day Men's Multi  3.28
31 Solgar Formula VM-2000 (Multinutrient System) 3.27
32 Bariatric Choice Once Daily Bariatric multivitamin with Iron 3.26
33 NOW Daily Vits Multivitamins and Mineral 3.17
34 ESUNM Complete Liquid Multivitamin 3.16
35 Methyl-Life Methylated Multivitamin 3.16
36 ProCare Health Bariatric Multivitamins 3.15
37 Andrew Lessman Essential-1 nuonce max Multivitamin 3.13
38 Bausch & Lomb Preseve Vision Eye Vitamin and Mineral Suppl 3.08
39 Nature Made Advanced Multivitamin Gummies for Adults 3.08
40 Nature's Bounty Hair, Skin & Nails Softgels 3.06
41 Solgar Multivitamin with Chelated Minerals 3.04
42 Pure Encapsulations PureGenomics Multivitamin 3.02
43 Kirkman Everyday Multi-vitamin  3.01
44 NaturesPlus Source of Life Original  2.99
45 Sports Research  Vitamin B-Complex 2.98
46 Life Extension One-Per-Day Multivitamin 2.97
47 Andrew Lessman Essential 1 Nuonce Max 2.96
48 Mary Ruth's  Liquid Nightime Multimineral 2.96
49 ProCare Health Bariatric Multivitamins with 45 mg Iron 2.95
50 Envitamin Methylated Multivitamin 2.92
51 Centrum Adult Liquid 2.92
52 ProCare Health Bariatric Multivitamins with 45 mg Iron 2.89
53 Deva Vegan Multivitamin 2.88
54 Nutricost Multivitamin with Probiotics 2.88
55 Jacked Factory Vita XT 2.87
56 Seeking Health Multivitamin One MF 2.87
57 Nature's Blend No Minerals Multivitamin 2.82
58 10X Health 5 - MTHF 2.82
59 Ultimate Multivitamin Multimineral and Superfood 2.82
60 Bariatric Adantage  Multi Chewy Bite 2.81
61 Life Extension Two-Per-Day Multivitamin 2.77
62 Celebrate Celebrate One 45 2.77
63 Barillife Just One with Iron 2.76
64 Tropical Oasis Mega Premium Multivitamin 2.74
65 Bariatric Advantage Multi Chewy Bite 2.70
66 Centrum Liquid Adults 2.66
67 Centrum Dual Action Multivitamin 2.63
68 Mary Ruth's  Liquid Nighttime Multimineral 2.62
69 Mary Ruth's  Multivatamin Gummies + Hair Growth 2.62
70 Bariatrc Advantage Innovations Advanced Multi EA 2.59
71 Methylated Multivitamin Multimineral Complex 2.56
72 MuscleTech Platinum  Platinum Multi-Vitamin 2.55
73 Thorne  Methyl-Guard Plus 2.55
74 LIFE Extension Two-Per-Day 2.54
75 Vita Fusion Multivites 2.54
76 Vitafusion MultiVites Gummy Vitamins for Adults 2.50
77 Envitamin Ultimate Multivitamin 2.45
78 Pure Encapsulations One Multivitamin 2.42
79 Nutracelle Nutramin Vitamin Gummies 2.40
80 10X Health D3+K2 2.39
81 Bariatric Choice Once Daily Bariatric multivitamin 2.36
82 Pure Encapsulations One Multivitamin 2.36
83 Mary Ruth's  Liquid Nightime Multimineral 2.30
84 Life Extension Two-Per-Day Multivitamin 2.27
85 Amazon Basics Adult Multivitamin 2.24
86 Nutricost Testosterone Support Complex 2.23
87 Celebrate  Multi-Complete 45 with Iron 2.22
88 Nature Made Zero Sugar Multivitamin Gummies 2.21
89 Celebrate Multi-Complete 2.16
90 Nature Made Multivitamin + Omega-3 Gummies 2.14
91 Dr Berg Trace Minerals Enhanced Complex 2.09
92 Double Wood Supplements Methylated Multi-vitamin 2.09
93 Nature Planet Soursop Graviola Concentrated Extract 2.06
94 Bariatric Fusion Bariatric Multivitamins 1.98
95 wholier Plant Based Multivitamin Vegan Omega 1.98
96 Bausch & Lomb AREDS 2 Eye Vitamins 1.86
97 Mary Ruth's Organic Hair, Skin and Nails Gummies 1.79
98 iMATCHME Soursop Graviola 1.76
99 Mary Ruth's Biotin Hair, Skin, Nails Gummies 1.61
100 OLLY Max Strength Sleep Gummy 1.49
101 Equate One Daily 1.34
102 Action Labs Essential Nutrients 1.29
103 Geritol Complete 1.22

Leave a comment

-->